Hello, my dear readers!
The up and coming wave of YA lit is upon us, with many authors having break out years and coming onto the scene for the first time. These contemporary novels are really exciting; it's fantastic to see the field expand into new territory! Contemporary YA lit has so much to offer and so many ways it can go that the possibilities are endless.
For Contemporary YA lit, I chose to read Love Letters to the Dead by Ava Dellaira. (You can check out her site here; on a side note, her layout online is really pretty.) This is Dellaira's first novel and she was mentored by Stephen Chbosky, the author of Perks of Being a Wallflower. The premise of Love Letters to the Dead is pretty straight forward. A girl named Laurel is starting high school after the death of her sister and is assigned to write a letter to a dead person for a school activity. She ends up writing a whole book of letters to a variety of dead people (Kurt Cobain and River Phoenix for example) and through the letters we learn of the events that lead up to her sister's death as well as the events going on now.
I have mixed feelings about this book. On the one hand, I really like the concept of it. Letters are a powerful way to explore a variety of topics that Laurel experienced, like abuse. But on the other hand, I can tell this is Dellaira's first novel and that she's trying to find her writing voice. That's not a bad thing, by the way; I love that this is her first novel and I hope she continues to write and develop her voice. I just got distracted at times by the way her writing is at the moment.
In our group discussion, we talked about how Dellaira is finding her voice. We also talked about how great the format is; depending on the person Laurel is writing to sets the tone of what we learn in that letter. So for those who died by suicide (like Cobain), the letters tend to be angrier and deal with the gritty stuff whereas letters written to those who maybe didn't die like that (like Amelia Earhart) are more upbeat about things. It's a really great technique that we hope Dellaira continues to use.
Honestly, I think Love Letters to the Dead is a pretty good book. It takes a little bit to get used to the format, but it goes quick once you do. I recommend it for freshmen and up.
~Meaghan
Showing posts with label group discussion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label group discussion. Show all posts
Sunday, May 10, 2015
Movie vs Book: Divergent and Group Discussion
Hi again, my dear readers!
One of the things that tends to happen (not only in YA literature) is that a book will become a best seller and then be made into a movie. Sometimes it happens the other way around - the book will be made into a movie, the movie becomes popular, and suddenly the book is a best seller. Either way, books and movies based upon them seem to go hand in hand. Sometimes the movie is better than the book; more often than not, the book is better than the movie. It depends on the reader, the viewer, and the overall experience.
For this class, I needed to read a book and then watch the movie. I chose Divergent by Veronica Roth. (The trailer for the film is here if you haven't seen or heard of it.) Divergent follows the pretty standard post apocalyptic YA novel format: everyone is split into factions in the society, a girl goes to get sorted and doesn't fit into just one category, she ends up becoming part of the warring faction, the girl is special, war breaks out, and there's romance.
(That sounds cynical, but go look at these dystopian books and you'll see what I mean.)
The movie is very similar, except that the actors and actresses are all incredibly good looking (which is a ploy to get people of the opposite gender to come see the film), the romance was toned down a bit, and the action was overplayed. Impactful lines and scenes got cut or altered as the director saw fit, all in an attempt to bring in box office revenue. And it worked.
In group discussion, we talked about how these dystopian films and books are so incredibly popular among teens. Film makers and authors seem to be piggybacking off each other and so more and more of YA lit and films are going the way of dystopian. We all agreed that it can't last forever. Eventually the market is going to be so saturated with things like Divergent that it won't be able to hold anymore and other genres are going to break through again.
We also talked about how the film ran compared to the book. The film is much faster paced, making it harder to absorb what is going on; the book, however, is slower and allows the reader to digest what's happening before moving on to the next scene or event. The film is good in that it allows visuals cues and images to be given, but it sacrifices some of the material from the book in order to do that. One idea was that if Divergent could be serialized like Game of Thrones is, that maybe it would work better.
As for me, I didn't really care for the book or the movie. I think I've had enough of the dystopian genre, though, so don't let that opinion stop you if you want to read Divergent or watch the film. If you decide to, though, I recommend you read the book first.
~Meaghan
One of the things that tends to happen (not only in YA literature) is that a book will become a best seller and then be made into a movie. Sometimes it happens the other way around - the book will be made into a movie, the movie becomes popular, and suddenly the book is a best seller. Either way, books and movies based upon them seem to go hand in hand. Sometimes the movie is better than the book; more often than not, the book is better than the movie. It depends on the reader, the viewer, and the overall experience.
For this class, I needed to read a book and then watch the movie. I chose Divergent by Veronica Roth. (The trailer for the film is here if you haven't seen or heard of it.) Divergent follows the pretty standard post apocalyptic YA novel format: everyone is split into factions in the society, a girl goes to get sorted and doesn't fit into just one category, she ends up becoming part of the warring faction, the girl is special, war breaks out, and there's romance.
(That sounds cynical, but go look at these dystopian books and you'll see what I mean.)
The movie is very similar, except that the actors and actresses are all incredibly good looking (which is a ploy to get people of the opposite gender to come see the film), the romance was toned down a bit, and the action was overplayed. Impactful lines and scenes got cut or altered as the director saw fit, all in an attempt to bring in box office revenue. And it worked.
In group discussion, we talked about how these dystopian films and books are so incredibly popular among teens. Film makers and authors seem to be piggybacking off each other and so more and more of YA lit and films are going the way of dystopian. We all agreed that it can't last forever. Eventually the market is going to be so saturated with things like Divergent that it won't be able to hold anymore and other genres are going to break through again.
We also talked about how the film ran compared to the book. The film is much faster paced, making it harder to absorb what is going on; the book, however, is slower and allows the reader to digest what's happening before moving on to the next scene or event. The film is good in that it allows visuals cues and images to be given, but it sacrifices some of the material from the book in order to do that. One idea was that if Divergent could be serialized like Game of Thrones is, that maybe it would work better.
As for me, I didn't really care for the book or the movie. I think I've had enough of the dystopian genre, though, so don't let that opinion stop you if you want to read Divergent or watch the film. If you decide to, though, I recommend you read the book first.
~Meaghan
The Graphic Novel: My Friend Dahmer and Group Discussion
Hello my dear readers!
One of the incredibly popular genres of YA literature is the graphic novel. Some people call these comic books, but in reality, they are so much more. The use of images and words to tell a story can give so much added depth for the reader - pictures can sometimes say more than words ever can, and the combination allows for multiple readings of the story while getting different meanings each time.
The novel I chose was My Friend Dahmer by Derf Backderf. Backderf went to high school with Jeffery Dahmer and chose to write and illustrate a graphic novel about it. I was drawn to it because 1. there's something fascinating to me about a serial killer and what made them snap and 2. the art is so interesting - like caricatures. (You can see what I mean by checking out Backderf's site; he posts weekly comic strips and stuff, which is always fun.)
The book was intense. The portrayal of Dahmer as this lonely kid who had a horrible home life and was just trying to fit in made me almost empathize with the guy. Backderf did a really good job at incorporating actual photographs of Dahmer throughout to ground the story and remind everyone that he was a real person; the cartoonish style makes it somewhat easy to forget that these things actually happened, and the photos break that up.
In our group, we talked about how the three of us who read the book immediately wanted to learn more about Dahmer when we were done. That someone could do something so horrible fascinated us. We wondered if things had been different (such as Dahmer's parents not being so wrapped up in their divorce or if Dahmer had been able to come out as gay without judgement) if he would have still done the crimes he did.
We also noticed that Backderf did a great job of changing the use of white space throughout the novel to show the downward descent Dahmer had - by the end of the book, there isn't any white space left in the panels, only darkness. The panels that had not words at all were also incredibly impactful. Seeing a young Dahmer walk through the woods at night by himself has a completely different feeling than if it was narrated in text.
Overall, My Friend Dahmer was a really interesting read. The style is great for people familiar with graphic novels and even if you aren't, the frames are done in a manner that makes it easy to figure out. I recommend it for mid to late high school students and above.
~Meaghan
One of the incredibly popular genres of YA literature is the graphic novel. Some people call these comic books, but in reality, they are so much more. The use of images and words to tell a story can give so much added depth for the reader - pictures can sometimes say more than words ever can, and the combination allows for multiple readings of the story while getting different meanings each time.
The novel I chose was My Friend Dahmer by Derf Backderf. Backderf went to high school with Jeffery Dahmer and chose to write and illustrate a graphic novel about it. I was drawn to it because 1. there's something fascinating to me about a serial killer and what made them snap and 2. the art is so interesting - like caricatures. (You can see what I mean by checking out Backderf's site; he posts weekly comic strips and stuff, which is always fun.)
The book was intense. The portrayal of Dahmer as this lonely kid who had a horrible home life and was just trying to fit in made me almost empathize with the guy. Backderf did a really good job at incorporating actual photographs of Dahmer throughout to ground the story and remind everyone that he was a real person; the cartoonish style makes it somewhat easy to forget that these things actually happened, and the photos break that up.
In our group, we talked about how the three of us who read the book immediately wanted to learn more about Dahmer when we were done. That someone could do something so horrible fascinated us. We wondered if things had been different (such as Dahmer's parents not being so wrapped up in their divorce or if Dahmer had been able to come out as gay without judgement) if he would have still done the crimes he did.
We also noticed that Backderf did a great job of changing the use of white space throughout the novel to show the downward descent Dahmer had - by the end of the book, there isn't any white space left in the panels, only darkness. The panels that had not words at all were also incredibly impactful. Seeing a young Dahmer walk through the woods at night by himself has a completely different feeling than if it was narrated in text.
Overall, My Friend Dahmer was a really interesting read. The style is great for people familiar with graphic novels and even if you aren't, the frames are done in a manner that makes it easy to figure out. I recommend it for mid to late high school students and above.
~Meaghan
Sunday, April 26, 2015
Science Fiction Novel: Feed and Group Discussion
Hello dear readers!
For my YA lit class, one section of material we covered was science fiction. The selection I picked was Feed by M.T. Anderson, a novel in which everyone in a future society has tech systems embedded in their heads that are constantly marketing to each individual. When the main character meets a girl named Violet who wants to break the system and break free of the "feed", he thinks she's nuts initially. But as the story progresses, he begins to understand why she's doing what she does.
(M.T. Anderson is a really interesting writer. If you go to his website, it's very much "steampunk" which I think speaks for his writing. I recommend checking out his books.)
In our group, we had an interesting discussion about the role of technology in the lives of kids today. Many kids can't be seen without their smartphones in hands, checking Facebook, Twitter, and Tumblr. The premise of Feed is that these streams would be pushed directly into the minds of everyone who had a "feed". The interesting thing is that Anderson wrote this novel in 2001, which was before the Facebook boom.
Another interesting thing about Feed is that the language is very dumbed down. The reason for this is to make a point that too much technology can reverse the learning process. We felt this was a very deliberate choice on Anderson's part; while it does make the novel hard to read in some places, it gets the feeling of this society all about consumption across well.
Overall, I enjoyed Feed. I think it could be a really good launch point for discussion with teens and adults alike.
~Meaghan
For my YA lit class, one section of material we covered was science fiction. The selection I picked was Feed by M.T. Anderson, a novel in which everyone in a future society has tech systems embedded in their heads that are constantly marketing to each individual. When the main character meets a girl named Violet who wants to break the system and break free of the "feed", he thinks she's nuts initially. But as the story progresses, he begins to understand why she's doing what she does.
(M.T. Anderson is a really interesting writer. If you go to his website, it's very much "steampunk" which I think speaks for his writing. I recommend checking out his books.)
In our group, we had an interesting discussion about the role of technology in the lives of kids today. Many kids can't be seen without their smartphones in hands, checking Facebook, Twitter, and Tumblr. The premise of Feed is that these streams would be pushed directly into the minds of everyone who had a "feed". The interesting thing is that Anderson wrote this novel in 2001, which was before the Facebook boom.
Another interesting thing about Feed is that the language is very dumbed down. The reason for this is to make a point that too much technology can reverse the learning process. We felt this was a very deliberate choice on Anderson's part; while it does make the novel hard to read in some places, it gets the feeling of this society all about consumption across well.
Overall, I enjoyed Feed. I think it could be a really good launch point for discussion with teens and adults alike.
~Meaghan
Wednesday, April 15, 2015
Young Adult Non Fiction: How They Croaked Plus Group Discussion
Hello again, my lovely readers!
A key component to education and to the reading curriculum of young adults is non fiction. Non fiction material can range from the funny and gross (which is what I read for this post) to the serious and grim. There are a few challenges in non fiction, especially for teens. It needs to be both engaging and factual, and somehow it has to hold the attention of someone who may or may not have the focus of a goldfish. The key with young adults is to get them reading what they are interested in, be it space, dinosaurs, fashion, etc. and use it as a launch point into other non fiction material.
(If you are looking for some ideas for non fiction for YA readers, Goodreads has a pretty great list here. A lot of these look really interesting, and can be a great way to get YA readers involved.)
For the non fiction selection, I chose to read How They Croaked: The Awful Ends of the Awfully Famous by Georgia Bragg and Kevin O'Malley. The book is filled with bios of famous people ranging from Mozart to Washington with facts about the time periods, practices, and other random bits and pieces. The book also has a lot of really funny drawings throughout as well.
I loved it. This is exactly the kind of book I was reading when I was in like 5th grade - the weird, gross out fact book was my preference of choice. I love how How They Croaked was humorous throughout, especially with some of the more gory deaths. I think by keeping the tone light it kept it from getting too dark. The facts were really neat, too; I had no idea Mozart died from strep throat. Overall, I think anyone in upper elementary through middle school will probably enjoy it.
In our group, we came up with a list of things we learned from How They Croaked, and if this list doesn't entice you into reading it, I don't know what else will:
1. Doctors could be just as lethal as the illnesses they were treating.
2. Thank God for antibiotics.
3. Always let someone know that you've died.
4. One of the leading causes of death is science.
5. Always do what you love, even if it kills you.
Again, a really great book.
~Meaghan
A key component to education and to the reading curriculum of young adults is non fiction. Non fiction material can range from the funny and gross (which is what I read for this post) to the serious and grim. There are a few challenges in non fiction, especially for teens. It needs to be both engaging and factual, and somehow it has to hold the attention of someone who may or may not have the focus of a goldfish. The key with young adults is to get them reading what they are interested in, be it space, dinosaurs, fashion, etc. and use it as a launch point into other non fiction material.
(If you are looking for some ideas for non fiction for YA readers, Goodreads has a pretty great list here. A lot of these look really interesting, and can be a great way to get YA readers involved.)
For the non fiction selection, I chose to read How They Croaked: The Awful Ends of the Awfully Famous by Georgia Bragg and Kevin O'Malley. The book is filled with bios of famous people ranging from Mozart to Washington with facts about the time periods, practices, and other random bits and pieces. The book also has a lot of really funny drawings throughout as well.
I loved it. This is exactly the kind of book I was reading when I was in like 5th grade - the weird, gross out fact book was my preference of choice. I love how How They Croaked was humorous throughout, especially with some of the more gory deaths. I think by keeping the tone light it kept it from getting too dark. The facts were really neat, too; I had no idea Mozart died from strep throat. Overall, I think anyone in upper elementary through middle school will probably enjoy it.
In our group, we came up with a list of things we learned from How They Croaked, and if this list doesn't entice you into reading it, I don't know what else will:
1. Doctors could be just as lethal as the illnesses they were treating.
2. Thank God for antibiotics.
3. Always let someone know that you've died.
4. One of the leading causes of death is science.
5. Always do what you love, even if it kills you.
Again, a really great book.
~Meaghan
Monday, April 13, 2015
Historical Fiction Novel: Between Shades of Gray Plus Group Discussion
Hello my readers!
I hope you are all having a lovely April so far. So in our YA lit class, we had to read a historical fiction selection. Historical fiction is a really important genre. Typically, a historical fiction novel will try to inform the reader about some time period or event, with the intention of making a connection between the reader and the characters so that the reader has a reason to be involved or to care. A lot of the time, a piece of historical fiction will act as a launch point to spark an interest in the reader. Once that spark is lit, the reader can then go find more information on whatever topic the novel was on.
For my historical fiction novel, I chose Between Shades of Gray by Ruta Sepetys. Between Shades of Gray is about a 15 year old girl named Lina who lives in Lithuania during WWII. The Soviets come in the middle of the night and take her, her parents, and her younger brother away to a work camp in Siberia. They face separation, hard labor, brutal winters, poor living and travel conditions, and starvation. There is a lot of death and a lot of pain. Lina is a talented artist and uses her drawing skills to make it through.
(Between Shades of Gray has a really great website as well. There are videos of the author talking about her book, group discussion guides, and reviews from critics. You can find it here.)
In class, our group talked about how we felt about the book. The general consensus was that it was a difficult read because there wasn't a lot of hope from the get go. As one of my classmates said, it was pretty much emotionally "shitty the whole way through", which made it difficult to stick with. But we also decided it was a really important read, as many of us had no idea about the Siberian work camps in WWII.
One activity we were asked to do was to come up with a list of everything important we took away from Between Shades of Gray. It was a really fun activity, so I'm going to post the list here for your enjoyment.
"Everything I Ever Needed to Know I Learned from Between Shades of Gray"
1. Blankets should never be taken for granted.
2. A parent's love is greater than you know.
3. Be kind to everyone, even your "enemies."
4. Not all people are bad, they just act bad under certain circumstances.
5. Time heals all.
6. Humans have the power to overcome anything.
7. Always find a hole to poop through.
I hope you will go read Between Shades of Gray. It really is an important piece of historical fiction.
~Meaghan
I hope you are all having a lovely April so far. So in our YA lit class, we had to read a historical fiction selection. Historical fiction is a really important genre. Typically, a historical fiction novel will try to inform the reader about some time period or event, with the intention of making a connection between the reader and the characters so that the reader has a reason to be involved or to care. A lot of the time, a piece of historical fiction will act as a launch point to spark an interest in the reader. Once that spark is lit, the reader can then go find more information on whatever topic the novel was on.
For my historical fiction novel, I chose Between Shades of Gray by Ruta Sepetys. Between Shades of Gray is about a 15 year old girl named Lina who lives in Lithuania during WWII. The Soviets come in the middle of the night and take her, her parents, and her younger brother away to a work camp in Siberia. They face separation, hard labor, brutal winters, poor living and travel conditions, and starvation. There is a lot of death and a lot of pain. Lina is a talented artist and uses her drawing skills to make it through.
(Between Shades of Gray has a really great website as well. There are videos of the author talking about her book, group discussion guides, and reviews from critics. You can find it here.)
In class, our group talked about how we felt about the book. The general consensus was that it was a difficult read because there wasn't a lot of hope from the get go. As one of my classmates said, it was pretty much emotionally "shitty the whole way through", which made it difficult to stick with. But we also decided it was a really important read, as many of us had no idea about the Siberian work camps in WWII.
One activity we were asked to do was to come up with a list of everything important we took away from Between Shades of Gray. It was a really fun activity, so I'm going to post the list here for your enjoyment.
"Everything I Ever Needed to Know I Learned from Between Shades of Gray"
1. Blankets should never be taken for granted.
2. A parent's love is greater than you know.
3. Be kind to everyone, even your "enemies."
4. Not all people are bad, they just act bad under certain circumstances.
5. Time heals all.
6. Humans have the power to overcome anything.
7. Always find a hole to poop through.
I hope you will go read Between Shades of Gray. It really is an important piece of historical fiction.
~Meaghan
Thursday, April 9, 2015
Identity Novel: Esperanza Rising Plus Group Discussion
Hello readers!
The identity novel is a really important part of YA literature, as it explores growth and issues that many teens are dealing with in some form or another. For my selection, I chose Esperanza Rising by Pam Munoz Ryan. Her website is found here and is full of all kinds of interesting things, including resources and discussion guides for her books.
The basis of Esperanza Rising is starting over from the ground up. Esperanza starts the story as a wealthy girl in Mexico during the 1920s. Her father is killed and she and her mother make an escape to California, where they work as laborers in the fields. At first, Esperanza is upset. The life in California is different than anything she's ever known and she hates it. But as the story continues, she starts to grow and come into her own, proving that even if you lose everything, you can still find yourself.
In our group discussion, we all latched onto the themes found in the story. There is smoke and fire (from Esperanza's home being burned), crochet and family (her grandmother teaches her to crochet and it becomes a lifeline while Esperanza is in California), and the fact that you can always recreate yourself. The biggest key we found to the story is the idea of cycles and circles. The book is structured after the agricultural growing season, and by the end, it has come a full season, much like Esperanza's life.
Esperanza Rising is a great book for upper elementary and middle school students, although I think everyone can gain something from it. I highly recommend it.
~Meaghan
The identity novel is a really important part of YA literature, as it explores growth and issues that many teens are dealing with in some form or another. For my selection, I chose Esperanza Rising by Pam Munoz Ryan. Her website is found here and is full of all kinds of interesting things, including resources and discussion guides for her books.
The basis of Esperanza Rising is starting over from the ground up. Esperanza starts the story as a wealthy girl in Mexico during the 1920s. Her father is killed and she and her mother make an escape to California, where they work as laborers in the fields. At first, Esperanza is upset. The life in California is different than anything she's ever known and she hates it. But as the story continues, she starts to grow and come into her own, proving that even if you lose everything, you can still find yourself.
In our group discussion, we all latched onto the themes found in the story. There is smoke and fire (from Esperanza's home being burned), crochet and family (her grandmother teaches her to crochet and it becomes a lifeline while Esperanza is in California), and the fact that you can always recreate yourself. The biggest key we found to the story is the idea of cycles and circles. The book is structured after the agricultural growing season, and by the end, it has come a full season, much like Esperanza's life.
Esperanza Rising is a great book for upper elementary and middle school students, although I think everyone can gain something from it. I highly recommend it.
~Meaghan
Non-Fiction Development: Writing Great Books for Young Adults Plus Group Discussion Notes
Hello readers!
For one section of our YA lit class, we needed to read a non-fiction book about development. The one I chose was Writing Great Books for Young Adults by Regina Brooks. It's a guide from an editor on what publishers are looking for and on ways to structure a young adult novel.
The book was pretty much how I expected it to be. There are sections that describe plot, characters, and climax. The key points of the book are that you need to gear the novel towards your audience and that you should really decide on a theme when you write.
There are some really good ideas in the book, and there are prompts to get you writing throughout, which is a feature I really liked. Brooks also brings up some good things to think about, such as remembering your audience and what it was like when you were a young adult.
When we talked about it in our group, most of us kind of laughed at the idea of coming up with a theme. For us, we write to just write. There isn't a goal in mind of a theme like harmony or friendship. I don't know if that will change when we get older, but for now that's how it is. We also discussed how the book reads like most other "how to write" books. Overall, there wasn't much in the book to differentiate it from others in the fields.
However, if you are interested in writing for a young adult market, I would still recommend you at least look at Writing Great Books for Young Adults, even if only for the writing prompts.
~Meaghan
P.S. - Here is a really neat article we read in class if you are interested in writing. It has some really cool ideas to get you started.
For one section of our YA lit class, we needed to read a non-fiction book about development. The one I chose was Writing Great Books for Young Adults by Regina Brooks. It's a guide from an editor on what publishers are looking for and on ways to structure a young adult novel.
The book was pretty much how I expected it to be. There are sections that describe plot, characters, and climax. The key points of the book are that you need to gear the novel towards your audience and that you should really decide on a theme when you write.
There are some really good ideas in the book, and there are prompts to get you writing throughout, which is a feature I really liked. Brooks also brings up some good things to think about, such as remembering your audience and what it was like when you were a young adult.
When we talked about it in our group, most of us kind of laughed at the idea of coming up with a theme. For us, we write to just write. There isn't a goal in mind of a theme like harmony or friendship. I don't know if that will change when we get older, but for now that's how it is. We also discussed how the book reads like most other "how to write" books. Overall, there wasn't much in the book to differentiate it from others in the fields.
However, if you are interested in writing for a young adult market, I would still recommend you at least look at Writing Great Books for Young Adults, even if only for the writing prompts.
~Meaghan
P.S. - Here is a really neat article we read in class if you are interested in writing. It has some really cool ideas to get you started.
Monday, March 30, 2015
Group Discussion: Forgive Me, Leonard Peacock
Hi there, readers!
This is a reflection of our group discussion regarding Forgive Me, Leonard Peacock by Matthew Quick. There will be spoilers, so you have been warned.
The first thing we talked about in group was how difficult this story was to read. We reside in Colorado and shootings are nothing new: every member in our group has been impacted directly by a shooting (Columbine High School, the Batman Theater Shooting, Arapahoe High School, etc). That tends to taint how you react to a book of this nature. Most of us were also bullied or depressed in high school, which also impacted how we read the text.
Once we got that out of the way, we were able to dive into the text. The biggest thing we found with the book was how Herr Silverman reacted. He saved Leonard's life and took the teen to his home for the night. But should he have really done that? Should Silverman have instead taken Leonard to the ER where he could be evaluated and held on a 72 hour hold?
The truth is, none of us were really sure where the line is drawn. As a teacher (most of us are education majors), what do you do in a situation like that? I don't think we ever fully established an answer to the question, either. The closest we got was that you do what needs to be done and deal with the aftermath later.
We also discussed whether or not this book helps or hinders young adults. The story has a lot of really good coping techniques that it shows the readers, such as when Herr Silverman has Leonard write letters to himself from himself in the future. And because the book deals with such a heavy topic, it can help others feel not so alone and show them there's more than what looks like the only way out.
The overall conclusion, however, was that it's a really important read that young adults should read, but they should read it with adults available. The idea of having adults available isn't necessarily realistic. Mostly, though, adults (parents, teachers, friends, etc.) need to be present to listen and help their teens sort through the information.
The concluding bit we came up with is that it's a very heavy but important book, but probably shouldn't be geared towards anyone below 12th grade unless the person recommending it is sure of the readers maturity level.
~Meaghan
This is a reflection of our group discussion regarding Forgive Me, Leonard Peacock by Matthew Quick. There will be spoilers, so you have been warned.
The first thing we talked about in group was how difficult this story was to read. We reside in Colorado and shootings are nothing new: every member in our group has been impacted directly by a shooting (Columbine High School, the Batman Theater Shooting, Arapahoe High School, etc). That tends to taint how you react to a book of this nature. Most of us were also bullied or depressed in high school, which also impacted how we read the text.
Once we got that out of the way, we were able to dive into the text. The biggest thing we found with the book was how Herr Silverman reacted. He saved Leonard's life and took the teen to his home for the night. But should he have really done that? Should Silverman have instead taken Leonard to the ER where he could be evaluated and held on a 72 hour hold?
The truth is, none of us were really sure where the line is drawn. As a teacher (most of us are education majors), what do you do in a situation like that? I don't think we ever fully established an answer to the question, either. The closest we got was that you do what needs to be done and deal with the aftermath later.
We also discussed whether or not this book helps or hinders young adults. The story has a lot of really good coping techniques that it shows the readers, such as when Herr Silverman has Leonard write letters to himself from himself in the future. And because the book deals with such a heavy topic, it can help others feel not so alone and show them there's more than what looks like the only way out.
The overall conclusion, however, was that it's a really important read that young adults should read, but they should read it with adults available. The idea of having adults available isn't necessarily realistic. Mostly, though, adults (parents, teachers, friends, etc.) need to be present to listen and help their teens sort through the information.
The concluding bit we came up with is that it's a very heavy but important book, but probably shouldn't be geared towards anyone below 12th grade unless the person recommending it is sure of the readers maturity level.
~Meaghan
Wednesday, February 25, 2015
Group Discussion: Before I Fall
Hello dear readers!
Today's post is a reflection of my group's discussion of Before I Fall by Lauren Oliver. If you need a refresher, the original review of the book can be found here. And as always, this will contain spoilers.
One of the biggest things we talked about in my group was whether or not Sam was actually reliving each day. One girl proposed that maybe Sam was comatose and the whole thing was happening in her head. I hadn't thought about it like that. The group was then pretty evenly split between those who thought that was the case and those who thought she was really reliving each day.
For me, the story loses something if she's in a comatose state. The changes in Sam's life aren't as impactful and it makes me wonder what the point was. So I believe, for the sake of my own reading sanity, that she really was reliving each day.
Another thing that came up was how impressed we all were at the fact that this is Lauren Oliver's first novel. It's incredibly complex and a bold move for a first book. Which is why we believe it got picked up and published; the concept is huge.
We also talked about the compassion aspect as well. The big thing all of us took away from the book is that it is never too late to change how you treat people, to be a kind human being. You never know how your actions will affect those around you, and it's so important to be kind and compassionate. It could save someone's life.
Finally, we discussed some things we wanted to ask Lauren at our upcoming Skype session. We decided we wanted to ask about whether or not Sam really was reliving each day and about her writing techniques and practices.
(Note: I was really sick the day of the Skype session. If I had been there, it would have it's own blog entery. What I gathered from those who were there is that Lauren was very positive that Sam did in fact relive every day in reality. She also gave some great advice about writing, specifically setting a word count goal. Her's is currently 1000 words a day, but she recommended that you start at 80 a day and work your way up. So disappointed I missed!)
Overall, all of our group members really enjoyed the book. We would recommend it for all high school students and adults alike.
~Meaghan
Today's post is a reflection of my group's discussion of Before I Fall by Lauren Oliver. If you need a refresher, the original review of the book can be found here. And as always, this will contain spoilers.
One of the biggest things we talked about in my group was whether or not Sam was actually reliving each day. One girl proposed that maybe Sam was comatose and the whole thing was happening in her head. I hadn't thought about it like that. The group was then pretty evenly split between those who thought that was the case and those who thought she was really reliving each day.
For me, the story loses something if she's in a comatose state. The changes in Sam's life aren't as impactful and it makes me wonder what the point was. So I believe, for the sake of my own reading sanity, that she really was reliving each day.
Another thing that came up was how impressed we all were at the fact that this is Lauren Oliver's first novel. It's incredibly complex and a bold move for a first book. Which is why we believe it got picked up and published; the concept is huge.
We also talked about the compassion aspect as well. The big thing all of us took away from the book is that it is never too late to change how you treat people, to be a kind human being. You never know how your actions will affect those around you, and it's so important to be kind and compassionate. It could save someone's life.
Finally, we discussed some things we wanted to ask Lauren at our upcoming Skype session. We decided we wanted to ask about whether or not Sam really was reliving each day and about her writing techniques and practices.
(Note: I was really sick the day of the Skype session. If I had been there, it would have it's own blog entery. What I gathered from those who were there is that Lauren was very positive that Sam did in fact relive every day in reality. She also gave some great advice about writing, specifically setting a word count goal. Her's is currently 1000 words a day, but she recommended that you start at 80 a day and work your way up. So disappointed I missed!)
Overall, all of our group members really enjoyed the book. We would recommend it for all high school students and adults alike.
~Meaghan
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)